Otterbein Homes for Sale

Welcome to Otterbein, Indiana – a charming small town nestled in the heart of Benton County. Known for its warm community spirit and picturesque landscapes, Otterbein offers a delightful blend of rural charm and modern conveniences. With a population that cherishes its tight-knit community, residents enjoy the peace and tranquility that comes from living in this idyllic setting.

As you explore Otterbein, you’ll find a variety of local amenities, including quaint shops, cozy cafes, and beautiful parks that invite outdoor activities and family gatherings. The town's rich history is reflected in its well-preserved architecture and friendly atmosphere, making it a perfect place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a slower pace of life.

For those considering a move, Otterbein boasts an array of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. Whether you’re in search of a charming bungalow, a spacious family home, or a cozy cottage, you’ll find properties that embody the essence of small-town living. Many homes feature expansive yards, providing ample space for gardening, play, or simply enjoying the serene surroundings.

With easy access to nearby cities and a strong sense of community, Otterbein is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Discover your dream home in this lovely town and become part of a community that values connection, tradition, and the beauty of everyday life. Explore the homes for sale in Otterbein today, and take the first step toward your new beginning in this enchanting Indiana town.

Newest Otterbein Homes for Sale

$275,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202629819 MLS ⋅ 1,836 SqFt. ⋅ Anthwon Thomas

Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home situated on a beautiful half-acre lot with room to spread out both inside and out! Offering a functional floor plan, this home features two comfortable living areas, a formal dining room, and plenty of space for entertaining or everyday living. The kitchen is equipped with new appliances installed in 2024, while major updates throughout the home provide added peace of mind, including a new furnace (2023), a new roof (2025), new gutters w leaf guards and an encapsulated crawl space with a new sump pump installed 2026. Outside, you'll find a large backyard with endless possibilities, including a dedicated area that's perfect for a swing set or play space, along with two generously sized storage shed for lawn equipment and seasonal storage. The back yard is fully fenced w/ cedar privacy fence installed in 2025. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or those needing extra storage will appreciate the attached oversized 2-car garage, plus an additional attached garage currently being used as a pantry and storage space. Two separate driveways provide ample parking for family and guests. With its spacious layout, recent mechanical updates, and expansive outdoor space, and the short commute to West Lafayette and Purdue this home is ready for its next owners to make it their own!

614 S Brown Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Anthwon Thomas from eXp Realty, LLC. 888-611-3912

$225,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202627487 MLS ⋅ 1,426 SqFt. ⋅ Chad Spitznagle

Well maintained 4-bedroom, 1-bath ranch with a private fenced in backyard on a corner lot in Otterbein. This easy-living layout offers a bright living room, an efficient eat-in kitchen, and four versatile bedrooms—perfect for sleep, office, or hobbies. The updated bath keeps things simple and stylish. Outside, enjoy a fully fenced backyard with privacy—ideal for pets, play, and summer cookouts—plus great curb appeal on a spacious corner lot. Practical perks include single-level living, low-maintenance exterior, and a small shed for storage.

515 W Oxford Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Chad Spitznagle from Weichert Realtors Len Wilson. OFC: 765-250-4644

$232,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202626487 MLS ⋅ 2,384 SqFt. ⋅ Sherri Baird

Space to spread out, room to grow. This two-story home offers nearly 2,400 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering plenty of room for however life fills it. Fresh flooring and paint run through much of the home, giving it a clean, move-in-ready feel. Outside, the corner lot gives you extra breathing room and curb appeal that stands out on the block. Step out back to a 12'x18' wood deck for your favorite activity-morning coffee, evening grilling, or just watching the seasons change. Storage and workspace won't be a problem here: along with the attached 1-car garage featuring overhead storage, you'll also have a detached 16'x20' garage, perfect for a workshop, extra vehicles, tools, toys, or all of the above.

26 Hancock Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Sherri Baird from Keller Williams-Morrison. Agt: 765-430-6229

$239,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202624990 MLS ⋅ 1,658 SqFt. ⋅ Gregory Vogel II, Gri

3 Bedroom House with Heated/Insulated 25x44 Det. garage w/ pneumatic lines and additional 20x32 det. garage in Otterbein. Close commute and Proximity to Purdue/West Lafayette Area. Fenced yard on a corner lot with a small town atmosphere but close to Purdue and Retail offerings of West Lafayette via US 52. Exterior updates include; replacement vinyl windows. Well Maintained house with Hardwood Floors, Original Wood Trim, High Eff. Gas furnace/Central a/c, a very efficient house. Kitchen has Oak Raised Panel Cabinetry. Large side Concrete Patio for outdoor relaxation. Neat/Clean House with Plenty of Big Toy Storage.

302 S Johnson Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Gregory Vogel II, Gri from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. gvogeljr@vogel-real-estate.com

$249,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202624876 MLS ⋅ 1,512 SqFt. ⋅ Lynn Edgell

3 bedroom 2 full bath ranch home with extra-large lot and attached 2.5 garage. Open floor plan with wood burning fireplace, newer laminate flooring, and decorative wood accent wall. Kitchen with tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, gas range, breakfast bar, abundant storage and countertop space. The oversized private yard is perfect for entertaining with the large paver patio.

705 Brown Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Lynn Edgell from @properties. 765-497-0700

$169,900

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202623845 MLS ⋅ 1,408 SqFt. ⋅ Grant Thompson

Located in the charming town of Otterbein, this 4 bedroom home offers plenty of space at a fantastic price. Many updates have been done in recent years including the roof and gutters (2017), garage door (2018), vinyl windows (2024), vinyl plank flooring (2024), water heater (2025), and AC condenser (2025). Additional updates include kitchen cabinets along with stainless appliances and a new water line that was recently installed from the meter to the home. Inspections are welcome, but the property will be sold as-is.

212 S Main Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Grant Thompson from Raeco Realty. 765-838-2785

$279,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202623713 MLS ⋅ 1,468 SqFt. ⋅ Christine McCutcheon

Show stopping 3 bedroom 2 1/2 bath home that has been thoughtfully rehabbed inside and out, down to the studs! The front door opens to an inviting open living space showcasing a vaulted ceiling in the living room which flows into a gorgeous kitchen with luxury updated gold finishes, granite counter tops and back splash, an island with bar seating and extra storage, custom cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances. The main floor also boasts a half bath for your guests, convenient located utility/ laundry room, and a primary suite complete with an en-suite bathroom boasting double sinks, a gorgeous tiled shower, private toilet, and a huge walk-in closet. Thoughtful updates include both internal and external insulation, ceiling fans, and a patio just off of the kitchen and double garage. Upstairs you will find two huge bedrooms with large closets and a beautiful bathroom featuring a bath/shower combination and luxurious touch enabled light up mirror. Located within walking distance to downtown and the local elementary school and only a short drive to West Lafayette and Purdue University. Book your showing today!

29 W 4th Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Christine McCutcheon from New Beginnings Realty. 765-464-4119

$210,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202621852 MLS ⋅ 1,592 SqFt. ⋅ Anthwon Thomas

Welcome home to this charming 4-bedroom, 1-bath property offering 1,336 square feet of comfortable living space. Inside, you'll find spacious rooms and unique cedar closets that provide both character and practical storage. Step outside to enjoy the covered porch, perfect for relaxing with your morning coffee or unwinding in the evening. The backyard offers plenty of space for outdoor activities, entertaining, or gardening, and features a cozy fire pit area ideal for gathering with family and friends. The detached garage provides convenient parking and additional storage, with even more storage space available in the loft above. Combining functionality, outdoor living, and timeless charm, this property is ready for its next owner to make it their own.

203 N Columbia Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Anthwon Thomas from eXp Realty, LLC. 888-611-3912

$344,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202621524 MLS ⋅ 4,574 SqFt. ⋅ Aaron Walker

Step into timeless charm with this completely remodeled 3,000+ sq/ft 1900s beauty featuring 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and the perfect blend of historic character and modern updates. Gorgeous original woodwork and trim have been preserved throughout, showcasing the home's craftsmanship, while soaring 9'+ ceilings create an open, inviting feel. The versatile den offers the potential for a 5th bedroom, home office, or flex space to fit your needs. Enjoy peace of mind knowing the roof, plumbing, electrical, and mechanical systems are all just six years old. Full basement with 2nd entrance. Located in a welcoming small-town setting, this move-in-ready home delivers classic elegance, modern convenience, and plenty of space for today's lifestyle.

103 E Oxford Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Aaron Walker from F.C. Tucker/Shook. 765-742-1400

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202618978 MLS ⋅ 2,002 SqFt. ⋅ Elizabeth Hobbs

This one is truly a MUST SEE! Located in the charming town of Otterbein, yet only 10 minutes from Lafayette and West Lafayette, this beautifully updated home offers over 2,000 square feet of remodeled living space with room for everyone. Step inside to find a spacious living room, family room, and formal dining room featuring gorgeous new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout. The fully renovated kitchen is a showstopper with brand new cabinets, countertops, and stainless steel appliances. A huge laundry room just off the kitchen provides excellent space for a pantry or mudroom setup. The thoughtfully designed floorplan includes a main-floor bedroom and full bath, while upstairs offers two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom. No detail has been overlooked with extensive updates including newer mechanicals, a 4-year-old roof and water heater, 3-year-old HVAC system, plus updated siding, windows, doors, trim, plumbing, electrical, flooring, paint, lighting, and more. Enjoy the nearly 1/3-acre lot with plenty of room for entertaining, cookouts, or relaxing outdoors. The detached garage provides extra storage space for tools and hobbies, while the adorable covered front porch is perfect for rocking chairs and morning coffee. Small-town living with convenient access to everything. Come see this charming home today!

210 Johnson Street, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Elizabeth Hobbs from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 317-459-1966

$630,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202616714 MLS ⋅ 2,340 SqFt. ⋅ David Maitlen

Imagine early mornings watching blue herons and bald eagles skim Otterbein Lake's water's surface while relaxing on your back porch or settling in for the evening admiring the sunset shimmering across 140 acres of Otterbein Lake. If you have been looking for a breathtakingly scenic and private location for your dream home, then this gorgeous brand new StoneRidge home is calling your name. Set on The Preserve at Eagle Shores, this home offers 1.545 acres, 2340 sf, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and many upgrades including hardwood floors, custom kitchen, large bonus room and gorgeous tiled master shower.

10264 E 975 N, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of David Maitlen from Maitlen Realty. 765-427-0783

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated