Otterbein Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Otterbein, Indiana – a charming small town that captures the essence of community living while providing easy access to the vibrant amenities of larger cities. Nestled in the heart of Tippecanoe County, Otterbein boasts a rich history, friendly neighbors, and a serene atmosphere, making it an ideal place for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

With its picturesque landscapes and well-maintained parks, Otterbein offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of urban life. Residents enjoy a close-knit community, where local events and seasonal festivities foster connections and create lasting memories. The town’s convenient location provides easy access to nearby Lafayette and West Lafayette, ensuring that shopping, dining, and entertainment options are just a short drive away.

For those considering a move to Otterbein, the real estate market offers an impressive selection of homes priced under $400,000. Whether you’re looking for a cozy starter home, a charming bungalow, or a spacious family residence, you’ll find a variety of options that cater to different tastes and lifestyles. Many of these homes feature modern amenities, beautiful yards, and inviting interiors, all while maintaining the warmth and character that Otterbein is known for.

In Otterbein, you’ll not only find a place to call home, but also a community that welcomes you with open arms. With affordable housing and a quality lifestyle, it’s no wonder that Otterbein is becoming a sought-after destination in Indiana. Explore your future in this delightful town and discover the perfect home that awaits you!

Newest Otterbein Homes under $400,000

$319,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202639888 MLS ⋅ 1,872 SqFt. ⋅ Sarah Kiefer

Beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering modern farmhouse style with small-town charm! Extensive updates include a brand-new kitchen with solid-surface countertops, new flooring, drywall, paint, HVAC, windows, siding, soffit, updated bathrooms, fixtures, and more. The spacious, functional layout provides plenty of room for everyday living and entertaining. Outside, enjoy the gorgeous wraparound porch, rear deck, attached garage, private driveway, and convenient alley access. Ideally located within walking distance to schools, park, library, post office, and local eateries. Enjoy peaceful small-town living while being just 10 minutes from West Lafayette and Purdue University. Move-in ready with the updates already done—this home is a must-see!

107 E Oxford St, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Sarah Kiefer from F.C. Tucker/Shook.

$187,700

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202636265 MLS ⋅ 1,014 SqFt. ⋅ James Cackley

Welcome to 502 W Darby Drive in the wonderful community of Otterbein, Indiana!! This fantastic ranch home has been updated throughout, offering an oversized 1 car garage with storage, a lovely eat-in kitchen with island, Hickory cabinets with a pantry & GE warming drawer, Quartz counter tops, counter depth refrigerator, windows, exterior doors and updated bath. With easy access off the kitchen, the backyard offers a covered deck to relax, a garden bed, a storage shed, newer gutters with leaf guards, and it's fully fenced!! You'll notice the long concrete driveway for plenty of off-street parking and the garage is extra-long as well with a work bench and built-in storage shelves. There are truly so many places for your extras, we foresee the new owners having no worries when organizing on move-in day! Go check it out!!

502 W Darby Dr, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of James Cackley from Cackley Real Estate.

$235,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202632789 MLS ⋅ 1,676 SqFt. ⋅ Jennifer Lane

Step inside this beautifully remodeled two-story home where timeless charm meets modern updates! From the moment you enter, the grand staircase makes an impressive statement and sets the tone for all this home has to offer. The inviting front porch is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy your morning coffee or unwind at the end of the day. The formal dining room provides an elegant space for entertaining, while the gorgeous open kitchen offers plenty of room to gather, complete with a tiled backsplash and a welcoming layout. A spacious laundry room adds convenience and plenty of room for storage. The primary bedroom is conveniently located downstairs, offering a private and comfortable retreat. The beautiful primary bathroom features a stunning tiled walk-in shower, creating a relaxing space to start or end your day. Upstairs, you’ll find three large bedrooms, providing plenty of space for family, guests, or a home office setup. Outside, enjoy the privacy of the fenced backyard and the covered back porch—perfect for entertaining, grilling, or relaxing with friends and family. With its beautiful updates, spacious rooms, inviting outdoor spaces, and tons of character throughout, this home is full of charm and ready to welcome its next owner!

409 E 2nd St, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Lane from Homeward Bound Realty LLC.

$269,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202618978 MLS ⋅ 2,002 SqFt. ⋅ Elizabeth Hobbs

This one is truly a MUST SEE! Located in the charming town of Otterbein, yet only 10 minutes from Lafayette and West Lafayette, this beautifully updated home offers over 2,000 square feet of remodeled living space with room for everyone. Step inside to find a spacious living room, family room, and formal dining room featuring gorgeous new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout. The fully renovated kitchen is a showstopper with brand new cabinets, countertops, and stainless steel appliances. A huge laundry room just off the kitchen provides excellent space for a pantry or mudroom setup. The thoughtfully designed floorplan includes a main-floor bedroom and full bath, while upstairs offers two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom. No detail has been overlooked with extensive updates including newer mechanicals, a 4-year-old roof and water heater, 3-year-old HVAC system, plus updated siding, windows, doors, trim, plumbing, electrical, flooring, paint, lighting, and more. Enjoy the nearly 1/3-acre lot with plenty of room for entertaining, cookouts, or relaxing outdoors. The detached garage provides extra storage space for tools and hobbies, while the adorable covered front porch is perfect for rocking chairs and morning coffee. Small-town living with convenient access to everything. Come see this charming home today!

210 Johnson St, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Elizabeth Hobbs from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 317-459-1966

$164,900

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202623845 MLS ⋅ 1,408 SqFt. ⋅ Grant Thompson

Located in the charming town of Otterbein, this 4 bedroom home offers plenty of space at a fantastic price. Many updates have been done in recent years including the roof and gutters (2017), garage door (2018), vinyl windows (2024), vinyl plank flooring (2024), water heater (2025), and AC condenser (2025). Additional updates include kitchen cabinets along with stainless appliances and a new water line that was recently installed from the meter to the home. Inspections are welcome, but the property will be sold as-is.

212 S Main St, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of Grant Thompson from Raeco Realty.

Start Your Search

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.